Warning Signs of Orthorexia or Binge-Eating
As a dietitian, one of my most important roles is to help clients not only develop healthy eating habits but also maintain a positive relationship with food. In today’s world, where we are constantly bombarded with messages about what we should or shouldn’t eat, it’s easy to fall into unhealthy patterns(physically and/or mentally), even when the intention is to live healthily. Two of the most concerning and increasingly common patterns I see in my practice are orthorexia and binge-eating disorder (BED).
Both of these conditions represent significant challenges to overall well-being, but they often go unnoticed in the early stages. Understanding how to recognize the early warning signs can be life-changing because early intervention can prevent these disordered eating behaviors from developing into more severe problems. In this post, I’ll provide evidence-based insights into what orthorexia and binge-eating behaviors look like, how to spot the early warning signs, and what to do if you suspect you or a loved one might be struggling.
What is Orthorexia?
Orthorexia nervosa is a condition where an individual becomes overly obsessed with eating foods they perceive to be healthy, to the point where it negatively impacts their life. Unlike anorexia or bulimia, orthorexia isn’t necessarily about the quantity of food consumed, but rather about the quality of the food and the need to follow increasingly restrictive rules about what constitutes "clean" or "healthy" eating. This obsessive focus on purity can lead to significant psychological stress and social isolation.
While orthorexia is not officially classified as an eating disorder in the DSM-5 (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders), research increasingly recognizes its impact on mental and physical health. Studies, such as one published in the journal Appetite, highlight that orthorexia is associated with both obsessive-compulsive traits and anxiety, suggesting that the condition can severely impair daily functioning.
What is Binge-Eating Disorder (BED)?
Binge-eating disorder (BED), on the other hand, is characterized by repeated episodes of consuming large amounts of food in a short period of time, often accompanied by feelings of loss of control, guilt, and distress. Unlike bulimia, binge-eating episodes are not followed by compensatory behaviors like purging, fasting, or excessive exercise. BED is the most common eating disorder in the United States, affecting millions of people, but it often goes undiagnosed.
According to the National Eating Disorders Association (NEDA), BED affects individuals across all demographics, though it tends to be more prevalent in those who have a history of dieting. Studies have shown that restrictive diets often precede binge-eating episodes, as the body responds to deprivation with intense cravings.
Early Warning Signs of Orthorexia
If you’re wondering whether you or someone you know may be struggling with orthorexia, there are a few key warning signs to look out for.
1. Excessive Focus on “Pure” or “Clean” Eating
Orthorexia typically begins with a desire to eat healthily, but this focus can become extreme. Someone with orthorexia may start avoiding entire food groups or foods they believe are harmful, even when there is no scientific basis for this restriction. For instance, they may avoid processed foods, sugar, dairy, or gluten without having a medical reason to do so.
This extreme attention to food purity can result in malnutrition, as people begin to cut out too many foods, depriving themselves of essential nutrients. A 2017 study in *Eating and Weight Disorders* found that individuals with orthorexia often show signs of nutritional deficiency, fatigue, and weakened immune systems due to these restrictive habits.
2. Obsession with Ingredients and Food Labels
One of the hallmarks of orthorexia is spending an inordinate amount of time scrutinizing food labels, ingredients, and food sources. While it’s perfectly normal to be mindful of what you’re eating, someone with orthorexia may feel anxious or guilty if they eat something that doesn’t meet their rigid standards.
This can escalate to the point where they may avoid eating out, social gatherings, or any situation where they can’t control what’s in their food. Research has shown that this behavior is closely linked to social isolation, anxiety, and depression.
3. Increasingly Restrictive Diets
As orthorexia progresses, the person’s list of acceptable foods shrinks. What may start as a gluten-free or sugar-free diet can evolve into a raw, vegan, or all-organic diet with little room for flexibility. Over time, this restrictiveness can lead to a very narrow diet that lacks balance and variety. Studies indicate that this rigidity around food often exacerbates feelings of anxiety and stress, as the individual becomes preoccupied with avoiding “unhealthy” foods.
4. Compulsive Exercise and Food Guilt
While orthorexia is primarily a fixation on clean eating, it can also overlap with compulsive exercise behaviors. Many people with orthorexia feel compelled to work out excessively to compensate for eating anything that falls outside of their self-imposed guidelines. They may also experience extreme guilt or shame if they eat something they consider "unhealthy."
Early Warning Signs of Binge-Eating Disorder (BED)
Binge-eating disorder presents quite differently, but it’s equally damaging. The early warning signs of BED include both behavioral and emotional indicators.
1. Eating in Secret or Hiding Food
One of the earliest warning signs of binge-eating is secrecy around food. Individuals may eat large amounts of food when they are alone, often at a fast pace, and hide evidence of their eating from others. They may feel ashamed or embarrassed about their eating habits and go to great lengths to keep them hidden.
2. Episodes of Eating Beyond Fullness
While most of us occasionally eat beyond the point of fullness, binge-eating episodes are characterized by a loss of control. People with BED frequently eat large quantities of food in a short amount of time, even when they aren’t physically hungry, and continue eating despite feeling uncomfortable or sick.
Research published in the International Journal of Eating Disorders suggests that these episodes are not driven by hunger but by emotional triggers like stress, anxiety, or sadness.
3. Feeling Guilt, Shame, or Distress After Eating
A hallmark of binge-eating disorder is the emotional toll it takes. After a binge episode, individuals often feel intense guilt, shame, and self-loathing. This negative emotional cycle reinforces the disorder, as many people turn to food again to cope with these feelings.
4. Frequent Dieting or Restriction Followed by Binges
One of the most common patterns in binge-eating disorder is the cycle of dieting and bingeing. Often, people with BED will attempt to compensate for binge episodes by engaging in restrictive diets or fasting. However, this deprivation leads to intense cravings, which then trigger another binge episode. Studies have shown that dieting is a major risk factor for developing binge-eating behaviors, as the body responds to caloric restriction by increasing hunger and cravings.
What to Do if You Recognize These Signs
If you suspect that you or someone you know is struggling with orthorexia or binge-eating disorder, early intervention is key. Both conditions are treatable, and the sooner they are recognized, the easier they are to address.
1. Seek Professional Help
Eating disorders are complex and often require a multi-disciplinary approach to treatment. A registered dietitian, psychologist, or physician who specializes in eating disorders can help assess the situation and develop a treatment plan. Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) is one of the most effective treatments for both orthorexia and binge-eating disorder.
2. Practice Self-Compassion
People who struggle with disordered eating often have a harsh inner critic. Learning to practice self-compassion and understanding that food is not the enemy can help shift the focus from restriction or bingeing to balance and nourishment.
3. Reframe Your Relationship with Food
Instead of labeling foods as “good” or “bad,” try to view food as fuel and nourishment. A balanced diet includes a wide variety of foods, and it’s important to allow yourself to enjoy all types of food without guilt or anxiety.
Conclusion
Recognizing the early warning signs of orthorexia and binge-eating disorder is critical for preventing these behaviors from escalating. Both conditions have serious consequences for physical and mental health, but with awareness and the right support, recovery is possible. If you’re noticing any of these signs in yourself or someone you care about, take action early by seeking professional help, practicing self-compassion, and reframing your relationship with food.
Click HERE to get 1:1 support as a nutrition coaching client! Health Insurance accepted.
