How Can I Set Goals for Body Composition Changes Without Becoming Overly Fixated on Food or Weight?

When I was in high school, I became obsessed with healthy eating after I joined the cross country team as a sophomore. I was looking for ways I could improve my endurance and drop time off my race. At first, it seemed like a positive change—I was learning about nutrition and taking care of my body. But what started as a simple interest quickly spiraled into something much darker. At that time, I would spend hours researching the “cleanest” foods, scrutinizing labels, and meticulously planning every meal. It even got so bad that I would get nauseous if someone else was eating fried foods in front of me. What I didn’t realize was that I was developing orthorexia, an unhealthy fixation on eating only what I considered to be the “right” foods.

My life began to revolve around food. Social events became stressful because I was terrified of eating something that wasn’t on my safe list. My energy levels plummeted, and I started losing weight, but instead of feeling good, I felt trapped. The more restrictive I became, the more anxious I felt. My identity became intertwined with my diet, and it was exhausting. It wasn’t until I went to college that I eventually stopped this obsession. It went away when I was no longer a year-round athlete.

That experience is what ultimately led me to become a dietitian myself. I wanted to help others find a balanced, healthy relationship with food and their bodies. Now, when clients come to me with questions about body composition goals, I understand the fine line between striving for improvement and becoming overly fixated.

Here are 7 tangible tips that I share with my clients, all rooted in science, to help set goals for body composition changes without falling into the trap of obsession.

1. Focus on Strength and Performance Goals

When setting body composition goals, it’s crucial to shift the focus from appearance-based metrics like weight or body fat percentage to goals centered on strength and performance. Research consistently shows that focusing on what your body can do, rather than how it looks, can lead to better long-term outcomes, both physically and mentally. For instance, a study published in the Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology found that individuals who set performance-based goals—such as increasing their strength or improving endurance—experienced greater motivation and higher self-esteem compared to those who focused on aesthetic goals.

Performance goals, such as being able to lift a certain weight or complete a specific number of push-ups, are more tangible and provide a clear sense of achievement. When you focus on improving your physical capabilities, you’re more likely to notice and appreciate the small, incremental progress you make, which can be incredibly motivating. Additionally, performance-based goals often lead to improvements in body composition as a natural byproduct. For example, increasing your strength through resistance training can help you build lean muscle mass, which not only improves your body’s appearance but also boosts your metabolism. This approach shifts the focus from external validation to internal empowerment, reducing the risk of becoming overly fixated on numbers like weight or body fat percentage.

Write down and work towards goals easier with this journal

2. Adopt a Flexible Approach to Eating

Rigid diets, with their strict rules and restrictions, can easily lead to disordered eating patterns and a strained relationship with food. Instead of adhering to a black-and-white mentality, aim for a more flexible approach to eating. Mindful well-balanced eating encourages you to eat nourishing foods most of the time while allowing room for less nutrient-dense options without guilt. This approach has been supported by numerous studies, including research published in the Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, which found that individuals who practiced mindful, well-balanced eating were less likely to engage in binge eating and more likely to maintain a healthy weight over time.

Mindful well-balanced eating helps you break free from the “all-or-nothing” mindset that often accompanies strict diets. When you allow yourself to enjoy a variety of foods in moderation, you’re less likely to feel deprived, which can reduce the likelihood of overeating or bingeing. Additionally, flexible eating promotes a healthier psychological relationship with food by eliminating the concept of “good” and “bad” foods. This not only helps you enjoy a more varied and balanced diet but also supports your mental well-being by reducing food-related stress and anxiety. Over time, this approach fosters a more sustainable way of eating, as it aligns with your body’s natural hunger and fullness cues rather than external rules.

3. Use Non-Scale Victories to Measure Progress

While the scale is a commonly used tool for tracking progress, it’s important to remember that it’s just one piece of the puzzle—and not always the most accurate or helpful one. Non-scale victories (NSVs) are other indicators of progress that go beyond the number on the scale and provide a more comprehensive view of your health and well-being. Examples of NSVs include improved sleep quality, increased energy levels, better endurance during workouts, and positive changes in mood. Research published in the International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity highlights the importance of recognizing NSVs, as they can lead to a more positive and sustainable approach to health and fitness.

Non-scale victories are particularly valuable because they encourage you to focus on the many benefits of a healthy lifestyle that aren’t reflected by the scale. For example, if you’re engaging in regular exercise and eating a balanced diet, you might notice that you have more energy throughout the day, that your clothes fit better, or that you’re sleeping more soundly at night. These improvements are often more indicative of true health and well-being than the number on the scale, which can fluctuate daily due to factors like water retention, food intake, and hormonal changes. By celebrating NSVs, you can maintain motivation and a positive mindset, even when the scale isn’t moving as quickly as you’d like. This approach helps you stay focused on the bigger picture—your overall health—rather than getting discouraged by short-term fluctuations in weight.

Stay hydrated while working towards your fitness goals

4. Prioritize Mental Health

When setting body composition goals, it’s crucial to prioritize your mental health alongside your physical health. The connection between mental and physical health is well-documented, and neglecting one can have a negative impact on the other. For example, chronic stress can lead to weight gain, particularly in the abdominal area, due to increased levels of the stress hormone cortisol. Additionally, mental health challenges such as anxiety and depression can lead to emotional eating, poor food choices, and a lack of motivation to engage in physical activity. Research published in the American Journal of Psychiatry underscores the importance of addressing mental health as part of any health and fitness plan, as individuals with better mental health are more likely to make healthier choices and stick to their goals over the long term.

One effective way to support both your mental and physical health is through mindfulness practices, such as mindful eating and stress reduction techniques like meditation or deep breathing exercises. Mindful eating, which involves paying full attention to the experience of eating without judgment, has been shown to reduce binge eating and improve overall well-being by helping individuals tune into their hunger and fullness cues. Additionally, regular mindfulness practice has been linked to lower levels of stress and anxiety, better sleep, and improved mood—all of which can support your efforts to achieve your body composition goals. By taking a holistic approach that includes mental health, you can create a more sustainable and balanced lifestyle that supports both your body and mind.

5. Set Realistic and Gradual Goals

In our fast-paced society, it’s easy to get caught up in the desire for quick results, especially when it comes to body composition changes. However, drastic changes are often unsustainable and can lead to disappointment, burnout, and even physical harm. Instead, it’s essential to set realistic and gradual goals that allow for steady progress over time. For instance, if weight loss is your goal, aiming to lose 0.5 to 1 pound per week is a more sustainable and healthy approach. According to research published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, slow and steady weight loss is more effective in the long term, as it is more likely to result in lasting changes in behavior and body composition.

Setting gradual goals is beneficial for several reasons. First, it reduces the risk of muscle loss, which can occur with rapid weight loss. Muscle is metabolically active tissue, meaning it burns more calories at rest than fat, so preserving muscle mass is important for maintaining a healthy metabolism. Additionally, gradual weight loss allows your body to adjust to changes more comfortably, reducing the likelihood of experiencing negative side effects such as fatigue, nutrient deficiencies, or gallstones. Moreover, gradual changes are more sustainable because they encourage the adoption of healthy habits that can be maintained over the long term, rather than drastic measures that are difficult to sustain. By setting realistic and gradual goals, you can make steady progress toward your body composition goals while maintaining your overall health and well-being.

6. Educate Yourself on Body Composition

Understanding what body composition really means is key to setting informed and realistic goals. Body composition refers to the ratio of fat to lean mass (which includes muscle, bones, and organs) in your body. Unlike weight, which can fluctuate daily due to factors like water retention, body composition changes more slowly and provides a more accurate picture of your overall health and fitness. For example, it’s possible to lose fat and gain muscle at the same time, resulting in little change on the scale but significant improvements in body composition. Research published in the Journal of Applied Physiology highlights the importance of body composition over weight alone, as body composition is more strongly correlated with health outcomes such as cardiovascular disease risk, metabolic health, and longevity.

One of the key benefits of focusing on body composition rather than weight is that it encourages a more balanced approach to fitness and nutrition. For instance, if your goal is to improve your body composition, you’ll likely incorporate both resistance training to build muscle and cardiovascular exercise to reduce fat. Additionally, you’ll focus on consuming a balanced diet that supports muscle growth and fat loss, rather than restricting calories to achieve a lower weight. By understanding the nuances of body composition, you can set more targeted and effective goals that align with your overall health and fitness objectives. This knowledge empowers you to make informed choices that support your long-term well-being, rather than getting caught up in short-term fixes or unrealistic expectations.

Add to your balanced diet with this yummy seasonal snack

7. Work with a Professional

Having a support system in place is crucial for staying on track with your body composition goals without becoming overly focused on food or weight. Working with a dietitian (like Shannon Cook MS, RD, LD) can provide you with personalized guidance, accountability, and support throughout your journey. Working with a registered dietitian can provide you with personalized guidance, accountability, and support throughout your journey. A dietitian can help you set realistic goals based on your individual needs, preferences, and lifestyle, and offer evidence-based strategies to achieve those goals in a healthy and sustainable way. Research published in the Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior demonstrates the benefits of working with a dietitian, as individuals who receive personalized nutrition counseling are more likely to achieve and maintain their health goals compared to those who attempt to do so on their own.

With my clients, I focus on helping them navigate the emotional and psychological challenges that often arise when pursuing body composition goals. For example, identifying and address any disordered eating patterns or negative body image issues that may be hindering your progress. A registered dietitian can also provide you with tools and resources to manage stress, stay motivated, and maintain a balanced approach to eating and exercise. Additionally, tracking progress in a way that goes beyond the scale. I often do so by using measures such as body composition analysis and strength assessments, offers a more comprehensive picture of your health. Consider scheduling a consultation today to take the next step towards achieving your health and wellness goals. By doing so you can ensure that your approach to body composition changes is safe, effective, and aligned with your long-term health and well-being.

Final Thoughts

Setting goals for body composition changes can be a positive and empowering experience when done thoughtfully. It’s important to approach these goals with a focus on overall well-being rather than perfection. Remember, the journey is just as important as the destination. By prioritizing strength, flexibility, mental health, and realistic expectations, you can make lasting changes without falling into the trap of obsession. As someone who’s been there, I can tell you that balance is not only achievable—it’s liberating.

---

Click HERE to get 1:1 support as a nutrition coaching client! Health Insurance accepted.

---

---

More By The Travel Dietitian…

---

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

---